Saturday, May 09, 2015

2015 and 2016 Gubernatorial Election Predictions

Final Prediction 2016:
Democrats to pickup IN, MO, NC
Republicans to pickup NH, VT
Three states will hold their gubernatorial elections in 2015 and eleven will in 2016.

Delaware 2016

Rating: Likely Democratic hold
Democrat: Congressman John Carney (likely) (incumbent Jack Markell term-limited out)
Republican: State Senator Colin Bonini (likely)
Overview: (7/22/15) Rest in peace, Beau Biden. Attorney General Biden was the presumptive Democratic nominee; now the blue team can expect a spirited primary. Given that President Obama carried Delaware by nearly 20 points in 2012, this seat is probably safe.
(4/9/16) Democrats have a top-tier recruit in John Carney. This race is over.

Indiana 2016
Rating: Toss up
Republican: Lt. Governor Eric Holcomb (incumbent Mike Pence retiring)
Democrat: Former Speaker of the state House John Gregg
Overview: (5/9/15) Mike Pence was until a short time ago considered a lock for reelection, and was talked about as a strong potential nominee for President should he throw his hat into the ring. That was before Indiana's recent ugliness with a Pence-backed law allowing businesses to discriminate against gays. Bizarrely, Pence repeatedly attempted to claim that the purpose of the bill was not to enable discrimination, despite the fact that the people he invited to the law's signing ceremony were anti-equality leaders who had lobbied for the bill specifically to enable discrimination. All this has not helped Pence's public standing (hey, even in Indiana you can only lie so much), and recent polls have shown a close race between Pence and former state House Speaker John Gregg. Gregg was Pence's opponent in 2012, and lost by only 3%; a good showing considering that Mitt Romney beat President Obama in Indiana by more than 10%.
(8/29/16) A conservative-leaning Monmouth poll shows Donald Trump leading Hillary Clinton by a whopping 11% here. The same poll shows Republican Holcomb leading Gregg by one in the gubernatorial, and, incidentally, Democrat Evan Bayh comfortably ahead in the race for the open Senate seat. I don't believe Trump is that far ahead, and other polls have shown Gregg ahead in the gubernatorial. Interestingly, Mike Pence is not helping Holcomb with campaign funding. Race is a toss up, but I think Gregg has a good chance to win.
(11/4/16) This is very close, but I'm calling if for Gregg.

Kentucky 2015
Rating: Leans Democratic hold
Democrat: Attorney General Jack Conway (incumbent Steve Beshear term-limited out)
Republican: State Agriculture Commissioner James Comer or former Louisville Hal Heiner (likely)
Overview: (5/9/15) The Republican party has pretty much run the table in the south, leaving Kentucky, with its Democratic Governor and state House majority, something of an oddity. Jack Conway is the best possible nominee for the blue team. Although Conway lost the 2010 Senate race to Rand Paul, he did collect a respectable 44.3% of the vote. The race on the other side is the epitome of Republican battles in the 21st century. James Comer, who's already won a statewide race, is facing an avalanche of personal attacks from less known, but more conservative Hal Heiner, who's being backed by the super-wealthy, super-evil Koch brothers. A divisive Republican primary can only benefit Conway, but on the other hand this is Kentucky and the Republicans will always have the inside track.
(10/26/15) Conway maintains a small but consistent lead in the polls. Republicans have never been very excited about Bevin or the quality of his campaign;  in late September the Republican Governors Association stopped airing ads on his behalf. It's possible that Republicans will get the better turnout and Bevin will win despite himself, but I'm calling it for Conway.

Louisiana 2015
Rating: Leans Democratic takeover
Republican: Senator David Vitter
Democrat: State House minority leader John Bel Edwards
Overview: (5/9/15) Even conservative sources are saying it: Governor Bobby Jindal has wrecked Louisiana. Coming into office with a huge state budget surplus, Jindal's aggressive tax cutting has created a $1.6 billion dollar budget deficit, and public services and education in Louisiana are simply disappearing. Jindal's likely successor is US Senator David Vitter, the prostitute-loving family values hypocrite. Now you might think that given the mess Republicans have made of Louisiana, Democrats might be poised for a comeback. Think again. Huge numbers of Democratic voters left Louisiana after Hurricane Katrina and never went back. Given the state's hard swing to the right, the Louisiana Democratic Party is having a difficult time finding candidates willing to be sacrificial lambs in statewide elections, and likely gubernatorial nominee John Bel Edwards doesn't have a prayer.
(10/18/15) The Democrats with a chance? Start with three consecutive polls showing that this will be a Vitter versus Edwards matchup, with Edwards winning the runoff between four and twelve points. Add to that an alleged former mistress who claims to have had Vitter's child, and that Vitter had urged her to have an abortion. This may be enough to cook Vitter's goose and send either Public Service Commissioner Scott Angelle or Lt. Governor Jay Dardeene to the runoff as Edwards' opponent. Either of those two gentlemen would be better than even money to win this race.
(10/26/15) Vitter won the jungle primary, although by a narrower margin than most expected. Conventional wisdom says Louisiana is so Republican that Vitter cannot lose no matter how may scandals he piles up, and I see no reason to doubt it.
(11/19/15) The runoff is this Saturday. Polls show Edwards with a lead between 6 and 16 points. Is that enough to win? Recently, the likely voter models used by polls in red states have been over-estimating Democratic support. Case in point, the aggregate of polls showed Democrat Conway with a slight edge in the Kentucky gubernatorial, yet he lost by 9. It's very close, but I'm calling it for Edwards.

Mississippi 2015
Rating: Guaranteed Republican hold
Republican: Phil Bryant (incumbent)
Democrat: Businessman Robert Gray
Overview: (5/9/15) Bryant will probably out-poll his opponent better than 2 to 1.
(10/26/15) Make that a Bryant win by 4 to 1. Mississippi is about as much a one-party state as it's possible to be.

Missouri 2016
Rating: Leans Democratic hold
Democrat: Attorney General Chris Koster (incumbent Jay Nixon term-limited out)
Republican: Businessman Eric Greitens
Overview: (5/9/15) Missouri is trending red; while President Obama nearly won there in 2008, he lost there in 2012 by nearly 10%. Somehow, Jay Nixon bucked the trend and was elected Missouri Governor in both those years. In 2016 Democrats should benefit from the fact that top-tier recruit Chris Koster has already been unofficially running and raising money for a long-time, while Republican support appears to be divided among several second-tier candidates.
(4/9/16) A recent poll shows Democrat Koster leading Republican Kinder by 2. With Hillary Clinton a strong candidate in Missouri, I like this office to stay blue.
(8/29/16) Eric Greitens was the surprising winner of the GOP nomination. Unfortunately for Republicans, Geritens is a political novice and has little chance of winning.
(11/4/16) Koster leads in every independent poll and I think he'll win.

Montana 2016
Rating: Likely Democratic hold
Democrat: State Attorney General Steve Bullock
Republican: Businessman Greg Gianforte
Overview: (5/9/15) President Obama is unpopular in Montana, and incumbent Governor Steve Bullock is polling no better than even against his potential Republican opponents. Thank goodness for the Montana Libertarian party. Their perennial candidate Ron Vandevender has already declared for this race. Vandevender captured 3.8% of the vote in the 2012 gubernatorial. Most of those votes came of course from folks who otherwise would have voted Republican, and, as Bullock beat his Republican opponent by only 1.5%, it's safe to say Vandevender handed Democrats the election. The same thing happened in the 2012 Montana Senate race. Incumbent Democrat Jon Tester beat his opponent by 4.0%, while the Libertarian candidate ate the Republicans' lunch in the form of 6.6% of the vote.
(4/9/16) Apparently, Republicans are not sanguine about this race; no major party leader has declared to take on Bullock. Democrats to get a free pass?

New Hampshire 2016
Rating: Toss up
Democrat: Executive Councilor Colin Van Ostern? (incumbent Margaret Hassan running for Senate)
Republican: Executive Councilor Chris Sununu (likely)
Overview: (5/9/15) Popular Governor Maggie Hassan will have no trouble fending off any of her potential Republican opponents. The real question here is whether Hassan will forgo reelection to take on Republican US Senator Kelly Ayotte. Democrats would dearly love her to do so, as polls are already showing Hassan could win. If this race does become a open seat, it might well go Republican as Jeb Bradley would be a strong candidate against whomever is next in line for the blue team.
(4/9/16) Governor Hassan's decision to run for Senate has left quite a vacuum. Both parties seem prepared to nominate lower-tier candidates (what the heck is an "executive councilor"? On the one hand, polls show Republican Sununu with the edge, on the other hand Democrats may have a big advantage at the Presidential level that provide coattails for their nominee in this race.
(11/4/16) Apparently "Sununu" is some kind of magic name in New Hampshire. Calling this one a narrow win for the GOP.

North Carolina 2016
Rating: Leans Democratic takeover
Republican: Pat McCrory incumbent
Democrat: Attorney General Roy Cooper
Libertarian: Lon Cecil
Overview: (5/9/15) Governor McCrory's approval ratings are pretty dismal. Democrats have a top-tier recruit in Roy Cooper, and he's polling well against McCrory. The blue team could also get some help in the form of the strong state Libertarian party. In 2012, Libertarian Barbara Howe captured more than 2% of the vote that would have otherwise mostly gone to the Republican candidate. Still, North Carolina is a red state and Democrats will need every break to win.
(4/9/16) As expected, polls show a very close race. If the Libertarian candidate can really pull 6% in November, I have to think McCrory is in trouble. I think the controversy surrounding North Carolina's new anti-LGBT law is not helping McCrory, but then again, who knows? This is the south we're talking about.
(8/29/16) Nothing has gone right in this race for McCrory and Cooper is now comfortably ahead in the polls.
(11/4/16) This one is close, but calling it for Cooper as he leads every polls.

North Dakota 2016
Rating: Likely Republican hold
Republican: Attorney General Wayne Stenehjem (incumbent Jack Dalrymple retiring)
Democrat: State Representative Marvin Nelson
Overview: (5/9/15) Dalrymple is more or less a lock. The only wild-card here is Democratic US Senator Heidi Heitkamp; she's threatened to jump in to this race. I very much hope that does not happen. If it does, Democrats can kiss her Senate seat goodbye.
(4/9/16) Republican Stenehjem is the stronger candidate, and in North Dakota that should be enough.

Utah 2016
Rating: Likely Republican hold
Republican: Gary Herbert (incumbent)
Democrat: ?
Overview: I had a dream where a Democrat won a statewide race in Utah. I also had a dream where it rained White Castle cheeseburgers. It's 1,600 miles from my house to the nearest White Castle.

Vermont 2016
Rating: Toss up
Democrat: Former state Transportation Secretary Sue Minter (incumbent Peter Shumlin retiring)
Republican: Lt. Governor Phil Scott
Overview: (5/9/15) Pete Shumlin was elected to a third two-year term in 2014, but only by 1% of the vote. Democrats have the Libertarian party to thank for that one, as they captured 4.4% of the vote that would otherwise have mostly gone to the Republican. Shumlin should have a much easier time of it in 2016 because it's a Presidential election year in deep-blue Vermont. In 2012, Shumlin won by more than 20% as President Obama carried Vermont better than 2 to 1 over Mitt Romney.
(4/9/16) If this were not a Presidential election year, I'd give the edge to Republican Phil Scott. But in 2012, President Obama beat Mitt Romney 66% to 31% in Vermont. With lopsided numbers like those expected again in 2016, it's unlikely any Republican can win a statewide race.
(11/4/16) A close race, and Clinton's coattails might be enough to carry Minter to victory, but Scott leads in all the polls and I'm calling this one for the GOP.

Washington 2016
Rating: Likely Democratic hold
Democrat: Jay Inslee (incumbent)
Republican: Seattle Port Commissioner Bill Bryant
Overview: (5/19/15) I live in Washington state. We've had three gubernatorial elections in a row that have been considered Democratic upsets, at least by some. In 2004, Christine Gregorie was declared the winner only after a recount. In 2008, many expected her to lose before she won comfortably. In early 2012, state Attorney General Rob McKenna was showing a wide lead in the polls over his opponent Democrat Jay Inslee; Inslee went on to win by 3% as President Obama crushed Mitt Romney in Washington by 15%. In 2016, I expect something more mundane. Republicans are talking about either Seattle Port Commissioner Bill Bryant, who doesn't seem to be much of a politician, or frequently-confused Congressman Dave Reichert as their candidate. Neither of those fellows worries me much.
(8/29/16) Bryant has not presented any kind of real challenge to Inslee in this race. Inslee will win.

West Virginia 2016
Rating: Leans Democratic hold
Democrat:  Businessman Jim Justice (incumbent Earl Ray Tomblin term-limited out)
Republican: State Senate President Bill Cole
Overview: (5/9/15) Both parties have several good potential candidates, but Democrats don't win very often in West Virginia any more. The question here is, can any Democrat get enough crossover votes to win this race, given that the Democratic Presidential nominee will probably lose West Virginia by a substantial margin? In the last four elections the answer was yes, but in those years the blue team also fielded must stronger candidates than the GOP.
(4/9/16) Jim Justice is perhaps the biggest name in business in West Virginia, and he's polling well against Republican Bill Cole. And although Romney beat Obama by 27% here in 2012, we may see a somewhat closer race at the top of the ticket this year which could help the Democratic nominee in this race.
(8/29/16) Justice is comfortably ahead in the polls; I expect him to win.

Sunday, March 15, 2015

A Few Links to Dispel Conservative Myths Part Six: Minimum Wage


"What puzzles me is why there isn't more indignation. The Tea Party is the most indignant domestic political movement since Norman Thomas's Socialist Party, but its wrath is turned in the wrong direction. It favors policies that are favorable to corporations and unfavorable to individuals. Its opposition to Obamacare is a textbook example. Insurance companies and the health care industry finance a "populist" movement that is manipulated to oppose its own interests. The billionaire Koch brothers payroll right wing front organizations that oppose labor unions and financial reform. The patriots wave their flags and don't realize they're being duped. Consider taxes. Do you know we could eliminate half the predicted shortfall in the national budget by simply failing to renew the Bush tax cuts? Do you know that if corporations were taxed at a fair rate, much of the rest could be found? General Electric recently reported it paid no current taxes. Why do you think that was? Why do middle and lower class Tea Party members not understand that they bear an unfair burden of taxes that should be more fairly distributed? Why do they support those who campaign against unions and a higher minimum wage? What do they think is in it for them?" - Roger Ebert, April 9, 2011

God bless you Roger, and may you rest in peace. It was to attempt to answer many of the questions that Roger Ebert raised in the quote above that I wrote this series. And nothing I can think of typifies the gulf between liberal and conservatives more than the question of minimum wage. Minimum wage is a philosophy; either one believes in it or one does not.

I believe that a higher minimum wage is the right thing to do, both morally and economically. Clearly my conservative friends do not. Consider a discussion I had with my right-leaning acquaintances. In late 2013, Nancy Salgado, a 27-year-old mother of two and employee of McDonald's made news for protesting the poor wages paid by her employer. After 10 years at McDonald's, she was making only $8.25 per hour, significantly below the poverty line for three people. Incredibly, the response by McDonald's to the inquiries of employees seeking information on making ends meet was to suggest that they apply for welfare. From Emily Cohn of the Huffington Post:

"McDonald's workers struggling to get by on poverty wages should apply for food stamps and Medicaid. That's the advice one activist McDonald's worker received when she called the company's "McResource Line," a service provided to McDonald's workers who need help with issues like child and health care."You can ask about things like food pantries. Are you on SNAP? SNAP is Supplemental Nutritional Assistance [Program] -- food stamps ... You would most likely be eligible for SNAP benefits," a McResource representative told 27-year-old Nancy Salgado, who works at a Chicago McDonald's. "Did you try and get on Medicaid? Medicaid is a federal program. It's health coverage for low income or no income adults -- and children.""

My reaction to this article was simple enough: McDonald's, a corporation that makes around $6 billion dollars per year in profits, should pay Ms. Salgado a living wage. Furthermore, it's wrong for large profitable companies to expect the taxpayers to subsidize their employees in the form of welfare benefits.

Here are some of the responses from my conservatives friends to my opinion:
1. You say she isn’t paid enough? Well, she should go find another job that pays more. If she doesn’t, she’s just lazy.
My thoughts: While the economy has made great strides under President Obama, I'm not aware of large numbers of job openings for work that pays a living wage available to persons with a background in food service.
2. What is she doing at McDonald's after 10 years? That's supposed to be an entry-level job. She should be studying for higher-paying employment. There's plenty of demand for software engineers.
My thoughts: The fact that Ms. Salgado has two children to care for, may not have finished high school, and has no money and no time for school will probably be an impediment to starting a new career that requires years of full-time training and outstanding study skills.
3. Why doesn’t she start her own business? She could sell tacos from a bicycle! (Yes this was literally suggested.)
My thoughts: The fact that she has no time or money to do so and no experience in starting a business will probably be an impediment.
4. Why doesn't she move to another city, stay with relatives and look for a better job?
My thoughts: Just quit her job, pull her kids out of school, and with no resources or transportation, move in with a relative (for free) and start pounding the pavement, with the assumption that there are higher paying jobs for her in her new city? That seems impractical.
5. Corporations CANNOT raise wages. Shareholders, "would not stand for it."
My thoughts: Clearly this is not the case. I'll point out some examples later.

But the most chilling part of the argument was this. I pointed out that minimum wage in the 1960s, adjusted for inflation, would be $10.75 in 2013 dollars. In 2015, the federal minimum wage is only $7.25, and with a Republican Congress, it seems unlikely to increase any time soon. Given that corporate profit margins are at an all-time high, and corporate taxation at historic lows, and given much-increased worker productivity over the past several decades, there's no reason why minimum wage shouldn't be at least $10.75, right? Wrong, say my conservative friends. People working in food service and retail are "unskilled," and "unskilled" people should always, no matter what, expect to live in poverty. The hatred many conservatives show for Americans working at the nation's largest private sector employers never ceases to amaze me. Recently, Erick Erickson, of both Red State and Fox “News,” stated that persons working at minimum wage are those who have, "failed at life," while California Republican Rep. Tom McClintock, said that some people are simple not "worth" more than $7 per hour. For the record, a working person needs to make about $10 per hour to be above the poverty line for a family of three.

Several of the arguments made by my conservative friends are coincidentally included in this Ruben Bolling cartoon (click the image to enlarge, or go to the link).


Putting aside the moral argument for a living wage, and the purely practical one against asking the taxpayers to subsidize large corporations in the form of welfare payments to workers, there's also of course the macroeconomic argument for increasing the minimum wage. As I discussed in my recent post on conservative economic myths, demand-side policies such as minimum wage inject money into the roots of the economy, that is, among working people and consumers. This creates a multiplier effect that generates growth upwards through the economy. This is because an injection of extra income leads to more spending, which creates more income for others. The American economy and personal incomes have grown more during the eras during which the purchasing power of minimum wage was protected.

One more thing before I move onto the myths and facts. In the balance of this post, I'll be talking a lot about Wal-Mart. Wal-Mart is America's largest private-sector employer, and typically pays poverty wages. U.S. taxpayers subsidize Wal-Mart employees by an estimated $6.2 billion per year in public assistance including food stamps, Medicaid and subsidized housing. Wal-Mart has also been known to hold food drives for its own underpaid employees. Recently, Wal-Mart announced it would raise its minimum wage for all employees to at least $10. That's still too low, but I applaud them for a step in the right direction. I'd also like to note that CEO Doug McMillon says the pay increase will "play through retention," and that he has, "acknowledged some of the criticism that the company has sacrificed customer loyalty because of its pay practices." I've argued before that if Wal Mart paid more, it would have a better workforce, and more people would shop there.


Part Six. Minimum Wage
Myth: "Most minimum wage workers are teens." - Mike Flynn, Breitbart.com.
"Most people on the minimum wage are significantly younger than me." - Republican Congressman Aaron Schock, age 33. (Update 3/17/15. Wow, Schock just resigned in disgrace.)
Fact: The average age of workers at or near minimum wage is 35, and 88 percent are at least 20 years old. Half are older than 30, and about a third are at least 40.

One additional thought. I see this myth quoted a lot. Apparently, conservatives are greatly comforted by the lie that America's low-wage workers are just kids making a few extra bucks after school while living comfortably at home with their parents, and not adults trying to make a living. As Andrew O'Hehier of Salon.com noted, "the working class has been convinced, in essence, that it does not exist. Workers in the service economy, at Target and Walmart and Starbucks, are seen as atomized, transient strivers – on their way toward college or the Army or the middle class or disability — and not members of any class at all."

Myth: A great many of Wal-Mart's employees are senior citizens already retired and working part-time, so they don't need a living wage.
Fact: While Wal-Mart does employee many seniors, fewer than 20% of its employees are 55 or older, and few people between 55 and 65 are already retired and working part-time; they're working full-time because they need to make a living.

Myth: Wal-Mart employees are paid above the poverty line. In 2014, the average full-time store worker was paid nearly $13 per hour.
Fact: Only 40% of Wal-Mart store workers are considered, "full-time." 40% are considered "part-time" and receive few benefits, while 20% are considered temporary and receive no benefits. Glassdoor.com calculates that Wal-Mart sales associates average $9.38 per hour, cashiers slightly less.

Myth: Wal-Mart is in an industry that simply can't afford to pay more than they do.
Fact: According to Glassdoor.com, Wal-Mart's big box store, Sam's Club, pays cashiers an average of $9.97 per hour. Sam's Club's competitor Costco meanwhile pays cashiers $15.87.

This Harvard Business Review study is now more than eight years old, but it's still a good summary of the both the difference between Costco's and Sam's Club's business practices, and the natural outcome of those same practices:

"Though the businesses are direct competitors and quite similar overall, a remarkable disparity shows up in their wage and benefits structures. The average wage at Costco is $17 an hour. Wal-Mart does not break out the pay of its Sam’s Club workers, but a full-time worker at Wal-Mart makes $10.11 an hour on average, and a variety of sources suggest that Sam’s Club’s pay scale is similar to Wal-Mart’s."

"On the benefits side, 82% of Costco employees have health-insurance coverage, compared with less than half at Wal-Mart. And Costco workers pay just 8% of their health premiums, whereas Wal-Mart workers pay 33% of theirs. Ninety-one percent of Costco’s employees are covered by retirement plans, with the company contributing an annual average of $1,330 per employee, while 64 percent of employees at Sam’s Club are covered, with the company contributing an annual average of $747 per employee."

"Costco’s practices are clearly more expensive, but they have an offsetting cost-containment effect: Turnover is unusually low, at 17% overall and just 6% after one year’s employment. In contrast, turnover at Wal-Mart is 44% a year, close to the industry average."

"In return for its generous wages and benefits, Costco gets one of the most loyal and productive workforces in all of retailing, and, probably not coincidentally, the lowest shrinkage (employee theft) figures in the industry."

"Costco generated $21,805 in U.S. operating profit per hourly employee, compared with $11,615 at Sam’s Club. Costco’s stable, productive workforce more than offsets its higher costs."

Myth: If fast food restaurants like McDonald's paid a living wage, they couldn't afford to operate; they'd go out of business.
Fact: An American hourly McDonald's crew member makes a pitiful $8.24 per hour. In Australia however, McDonald's operates 900 restaurants. The minimum wage there is about $14.50 per hour. Food prices at Australian McDonald's are only 1% to 17% higher than the United States. McDonald's also operate more than 1,200 restaurants in France, where minimum wage is about $12 per hour.

Myth: If Wal-Mart paid a living wage, it would have to raise prices substantially to maintain its earnings.
Fact: According to a 2011 study, raising the wages of all Walmart workers making below $12 per hour up to that hourly wage would cost the average Walmart shopper only 46 cents per trip. And figure of course doesn't even count the more difficult to quantify benefits that would come about as a result: a more loyal Wal-Mart workforce and more sales (people who work at Wal-Mart spend a lot of money there).

Myth: Wal-Mart may not pay well, but they create a lot of jobs.
Fact: According to a 2007 study from the University of California, Irvine, Wal-Mart destroys three jobs for every two it creates. According the Economic Policy Institute, Wal-Mart's practices of importing goods from China cost the United States nearly 200,00 jobs, principally in manufacturing, between 2001 and 2006.

Myth: Wal-Mart may not pay well, but things are cheaper there than at other stores.
Fact: Research by Bloomberg Industries in 2012 showed Target stores to actually be cheaper than Wal-Mart. Another study found Kroger's groceries to be cheaper than Wal-Mart's. (Of course Target and Kroger also pay workers poorly.)

Myth: If Wal-Mart isn't paying it's employees more, then they just can't afford to.
Fact: I hear this one sometimes as a "common sense" argument. It's just "common sense" that Wal-Mart's directors are good people and pay as much as they can "afford to," right? Wrong. Sam Walton himself said, "I pay low wages. I can take advantage of that. We're going to be successful, but the basis is a very low-wage, low-benefit model of employment." So how much does, Wal-Mart "take advantage" of its low-wage model? In the second quarter of 2014, Wal-Mart made $4.09 billion in profits. Sam Walton's adult children own just over 50% of the company, and receive over $3 billion in dividends every year. Can Wal-Mart "afford" to pay its employees more? Yes it can.

Myth: Raising the minimum wage will destroy jobs, because some companies can't afford to pay more.
Fact: A 2010 study from the Center for Economic and Policy Research found little if any negative effect of minimum wage increases on employment. A study that same year from the University of Massachusetts-Amherst found, "strong earnings effects and no employment effects of minimum wage increases." Nobel-prize winning economist Paul Krugman says raising minimum wage to $9 an hour would have, "overwhelmingly positive effects."

Last year, the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office weighed in on the issue, releasing a report that found an increase to $10.10 an hour by 2016 would increase the wages of 25 million Americans, but also cost the economy around 500,000 jobs. Republicans were quick to pounce on the 500,000 job losses number of course, never mind that the CBO was saying that 50 people would benefit from a $10.10 minimum wage for every one person who had to look for a new job. Economists were however quick to point out that the CBO is out of step with what other studies are saying about increasing the minimum wage and job losses. Paul Zornick of the Nation notes that, "Past meta-analyses have found that, of the many studies that have been done, the conclusions cluster around zero for job loss estimates."

Put it another way. The federal minimum wages was raised from $5.15 per hour in 2006 to $7.25 per hour in 2009, an increase of more than 40%. Far from seeing job losses, the economy has seen 60 consecutive months of private-sector job growth, more than 12 million jobs total. My home state of Washington has a booming economy; our minimum wage is $9.47, highest in the U.S. In April of 2015, the minimum wage for large businesses in Seattle will go to $11 per hour, and will reach $15 per hour in 2019. Has this scared businesses away? Far from it. Seattle is America's fastest growing large city. Finally, there's currently a story going around cyberspace that the new higher minimum wage is causing some Seattle restaurants to close. That it also a myth.

Myth: Raising the minimum wage will cause inflation.
Fact: A 2006 study of study from the University of Massachusetts-Amherst found that a 10% minimum wage increase would produce a cost increase for the average business of less than one-tenth of one percent of their sales revenue. Or again, let's go back to the 40% minimum wage between 2006 and 2009. Since 2009, inflation has been substantially below that of the previous decade.

In conclusion, a 2013 poll showed that four out of five Americans support increasing minimum wage to $10.10. So do three out of five small business owners, and more than 600 economists. For more minimum wage mythbusters, go here. I expect this post to be the conclusion of my series on conservative myths, until some new ones have had a chance to propagate.

Thank you. Good night, and good luck.

Sunday, January 25, 2015

A Few Links to Dispel Conservative Myths Part Five: Entitlements and Life in America

It seems I'm on the same wavelength as economist Paul Krugman, who happens to be a hero of mine. Like me, Paul has been thinking about conservative myths, and why they exist:

"Indeed, at this point it’s hard to think of a major policy dispute where facts actually do matter; it’s unshakable dogma, across the board. And the real question is why."

Discussing some of the same subjects I've covered in this series of posts, including global warming, Obamacare and the failure of supply-side economics, Paul says,

"On issues that range from monetary policy to the control of infectious disease, a big chunk of America’s body politic holds views that are completely at odds with, and completely unmovable by, actual experience."

"Well, it strikes me that the immovable position in each of these cases is bound up with rejecting any role for government that serves the public interest. If you don’t want the government to impose controls or fees on polluters, you want to deny that there is any reason to limit emissions. If you don’t want the combination of regulation, mandates and subsidies that is needed to extend coverage to the uninsured, you want to deny that expanding coverage is even possible. And claims about the magical powers of tax cuts are often little more than a mask for the real agenda of crippling government by starving it of revenue."

"And why this hatred of government in the public interest? Well, the political scientist Corey Robin argues that most self-proclaimed conservatives are actually reactionaries. That is, they’re defenders of traditional hierarchy — the kind of hierarchy that is threatened by any expansion of government, even (or perhaps especially) when that expansion makes the lives of ordinary citizens better and more secure. I’m partial to that story, partly because it helps explain why climate science and health economics inspire so much rage."

I couldn't have said it better myself. In this post, I'll be covering conservatives myth regarding welfare programs and other entitlements, as well as few other myths that don't fit neatly into another category.

Myth: Welfare programs failed to reduce poverty and have actually made life worse rather than better for recipients. This is particularly true for black Americans.
Fact: Welfare as we know it is generally understood to have begun with President Kennedy's New Frontier program in 1961 and to have continued with President Johnson's Great Society - the "war on poverty". Ever since then, it's slowly withered away. What was once a series of comprehensive programs to create jobs, improve education and build the country's infrastructure now consists principally of the federal food stamp program and some limited cash grants from states.

But have these programs failed to reduce poverty? No. On the contrary, they've been very successful.
* Under Presidents Kennedy and Johnson, the poverty rate fell from 23% to 12%. After the Johnson era, the "war on poverty" was largely curtailed, and the poverty rate hasn't changed much ever since. The poverty rate for black Americans has declined steadily, from 55% in 1959, to 30% in 1975 to 25% in 2012.
* Since the early 1960s, high school graduation rates have nearly doubled for white Americans. For black Americans, they more than tripled from 24% in 1962, to 38% in 1972 to 80% in 2012.
* Since the mid 1960s, median household income has risen about 20% for both white and black Americans.

Myth: Welfare programs have made recipients dependent on welfare and given them a poor work ethic.
Fact: About half of working-age adults receiving food stamps have jobs. They continue to qualify for food stamps for because America's largest corporations pay below the poverty line. Wal Mart alone costs taxpayers $6.2 billion per year in public assistance. Many other recipients are past working age or are unable to work. 82 percent of all Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits go to vulnerable houses that include a child, elderly person, or disabled person.
The idea that welfare recipients are "dependent" suggests they prefer welfare to work. I have never seen any data to suggest that jobs are going unfilled in areas with many welfare recipients. In 2011, one million persons applied for 62,000 jobs at McDonald's; this hardly suggests that America's poor unemployed folks are not looking for work.

Myth: Welfare is responsible for a dramatic increase in single-parent households.
Fact: It's true that the percentage of families that are single- rather than two-parent has risen dramatically since 1950. However, the percentage of families that are single-parent rose most dramatically in the 1970s and 80s, when welfare programs were being dramatically scaled back rather than expanded. The percentage of poor families receiving federal aid fell from 82% in 1979 to 27% in 2010, while at the same time the percentage of families with only one parent increased from 19% to 30%.

Myth: The food stamp program and other government welfare programs are subject to a great deal of waste and fraud.
Fact: According to the Department of Agriculture, the rate of fraud in the food stamp program is one cent on the dollar. An investigation of welfare programs in the state of Maine found that less than one percent of welfare funds were used for inappropriate transactions.

Myth: High incidence of illicit drug use suggests that it is worthwhile to drug test welfare recipients.
Fact: Few welfare recipients use drugs. A Florida investigation of that state's welfare program found that about 2.5 percent of welfare recipients had tested positive for drugs since a testing law went into effect there. In Tennessee, exactly one (1) of the first 800 welfare recipients tested there tested positive for illicit drug use. The 2010 National Survey on Drug Use and Health found an estimated 22.6 million Americans aged 12 or older—8.9 percent of the population—were current illicit drug users.

Myth: Many people who receive disability payments are not really disabled.
"What I tell people is, if you look like me and you hop out of your truck, you shouldn’t be getting a disability check. Over half of the people on disability are either anxious or their back hurts — join the club. Who doesn’t get a little anxious for work and their back hurts?  Everybody over 40 has a back pain. And I am not saying that there are not legitimately people who are disabled.  But the people who are the malingerers are the ones taking the money away from the people who are paraplegic, quadriplegic. You know, we all know people who are horrifically disabled and can’t work, but if you have able bodied people taking the money, then there is not enough money for the people who are truly disabled." - Senator Rand Paul, 1/14/15
Fact: From the Washington Post, "Indeed, it is not easy to qualify for disability. According to SSA, between 2003 and 2012, only 24 percent of disability applicants were initially granted benefits; an average of two and 11 percent were awarded benefits after either reconsideration or a hearing, respectively. Thus an average of 59 percent of applicants were denied benefits, even after appeals." The Post further called Senator Paul remarks untrue, saying, "But not only is the rate of fraud relatively low, but it mostly involves people who are working who should not be getting payments, rather than people who are getting paid and not working. Moreover, even a generous interpretation of the data does not generate a figure close to more than half of beneficiaries getting paid for simply back pain and anxiety." Politifact.com also rated Paul's claims, "false."

Myth: Incidence of voter fraud necessitates voter ID laws that require voters to obtain and show a photo ID before voting.
Fact: Voter fraud is virtually non-existent in the United States. These laws disproportionally impact women, the poor and minorities. Numerous Republicans have admitted these laws are designed to disenfranchise Democrats.

Myth: The socialized health care systems of other nations are going broke and/or have other major problems that make them undesirable. Those systems ration care.
Fact: Other leading industrialized nations, all of whom have socialized, national health-care systems, spend one-third to one-half what the United States has been spending on health care per capita. It is routinely more difficult to obtain care in the United States than in European countries. There are fewer doctors and hospital beds per capita in America than in most leading industrialized countries.

Myth: Medicare is inferior to private health care.
Fact: Medicare beats private plans in terms of customer satisfaction. Medicare also has less administrative overhead cost.

Myth: The US Postal Service is running a huge deficit, indicative of a bloated, inefficient government bureaucracy.
Fact: USPS turned a $660 million profit delivering mail in fiscal year 2013. Unfortunately, the post office is the victim of a Congressional scheme to make it look bad in order to justify downsizing it to the benefit of private interests. In 2006, Congress passed legislation that unnecessarily required USPS to pre-fund – within 10 years – most retiree healthcare benefits for the next 75 years. This makes it appear as if USPS is running a deficit. The Congressmen advocating the downsizing of the post office have, not coincidentally, received a lot of campaign contributions from private sectors competitors to USPS such as FedEx and UPS.
In 2006, Congress passed legislation that required USPS to pre-fund – within 10 years – most retiree healthcare benefits for the next 75 years. - See more at: http://deliveringforamerica.com/latest-news/debunking-the-postal-service-default/#sthash.FPgWiD26.dpuf
In 2006, Congress passed legislation that required USPS to pre-fund – within 10 years – most retiree healthcare benefits for the next 75 years. - See more at: http://deliveringforamerica.com/latest-news/debunking-the-postal-service-default/#sthash.FPgWiD26.dpuf
In 2006, Congress passed legislation that required USPS to pre-fund – within 10 years – most retiree healthcare benefits for the next 75 years. - See more at: http://deliveringforamerica.com/latest-news/debunking-the-postal-service-default/#sthash.FPgWiD26.dpuf

Myth: Charter schools are superior to public schools.
Fact: A 2009 Stanford study found that on average privatized charter schools were not performing as well as their traditional public-school peers. An updated 2013 found similar results.

Myth: Carrying a handgun in public increases public safety.
Fact: A 2009 University of Pennsylvania study found that individuals in possession of a gun were 4.5 times more likely to be shot in an assault than those not in possession. A 2014 Stanford study found that right-to-carry gun laws are connected with an increase in violent crime.

Myth: "Law-abiding citizens use guns to defend themselves against criminals as many as 2.5 million times every year -- or about 6,850 times a day. This means that each year, firearms are used more than 80 times more often to protect the lives of honest citizens than to take lives." - Gun Owners of America
Fact: I wrote about this one in 2012. Long story short, in 1994 a university study contacted a small number of people and asked them if they'd used a gun to defend their property. Gun Owners of America then extrapolated (and completely twisted) the results of that survey into the quote above. So how often are guns actually used defensively in America? According to a Department of Justice Study from the 1990s, about 38 times a day, or about 0.4% as often as GOA claims. Put it another way. The total number of people shot by guns in the US in 2008 totaled 110,215. This suggests that between 10 and 11 Americans suffer a gun injury for every instance of a gun being used defensively.

Myth: The rate of gun ownership in rural America is much higher than in urban areas, and there are far fewer murders, demonstrating that higher gun ownership rates mean more public safety.
Fact: While the gun ownership rate in rural America is double that of urban areas, gun deaths per capita are actually far higher in states that are primarily rural than in states where most people live in cities.
Deaths by firearm per 100K population, rural states:
Alabama: 16.2, Alaska: 20.4, Arizona: 14.6, New Mexico: 14.9
.
Deaths by firearm per 100K population, urban states: California: 7.7, Illinois: 8.2, New Jersey: 5.2, New York: 5.1.

Myth: Senator Diane Feinstein of California, a key supporter of the now-expired 1994 assault weapons ban, called for an outright ban on all firearms. "First, while she now contends that her intent is simply to restrict certain “bad” guns (based upon totally arbitrary criteria her staff has established), that claim doesn’t jibe with what she told CBS’s 60 Minutes. Upon seeing her Clinton gun ban enacted in 1994, she said: “If I could have gotten 51 votes in the Senate of the United States for an outright ban, picking up every one of them . . . ‘Mr. and Mrs. America, turn ‘em all in,’ I would have done it."" - Forbes.com editorial
Fact: The assault weapons ban covered only manufacture. Senator Feinstein's remarks were meant to convey that she supported expanding the law to cover possession of assault weapons as well. Feinstein is actually a supporter of handgun ownership and concealed-carry rights.

Myth: President John F. Kennedy supported lower taxes, so he was a conservative on fiscal policy issues.
Fact: JFK proposed a law to lower the top individual tax rate to 65% and corporate rate to 47%. He believed in raising the minimum wage, welfare programs, public works programs,expanded union rights including government employees, Medicare, civil rights and desegregation programs, voting rights programs, women's equality programs, a Clean Air Act and greatly expanded public housing. If that's Republicanism, then I'm Abraham Lincoln.

Myth: Let's use a flat tax to tax everyone at the same rate. That would be fairer!
Fact: Strictly speaking, this one doesn't belong in this blog post. Myth versus fact is objective, "fairness" is subjective; you can argue that anything is fair or unfair. However Herman Cain's "9-9-9 plan" and similar flat-tax plans are definitely unfair unless you want to increase the growing income inequalities we've been experiencing for years. From Robert H. Frank of the New York Times:

"The much more serious concern is that a flat tax would reinforce the trends toward greater income inequality that have been seen over the last several decades. As documented by a recent Congressional Budget Office study, the top 1 percent of income recipients in the United States earned 275 percent more in 2007 than they did in 1979, adjusted for inflation, a period when the earnings of middle-income households grew by less than 40 percent. A flat tax would increase inequality by substantially reducing rates on the most prosperous households, while increasing them on low- and middle-income households.

According to an analysis by the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center, Mr. Cain’s proposal would increase the annual tax bill of a typical family of four earning $50,000 a year by more than $4,000, but would reduce the taxes owed by a similar family earning between $500,000 and $1 million by almost $60,000. The center also estimated that families in the top one-tenth of 1 percent of households would enjoy an average annual tax reduction of nearly $1.4 million under the Cain plan. Similar distributional effects are common under all flat-tax plans, not just Mr. Cain’s."

Myth: President Obama has taken outrageous amounts of vacation time.
Fact: President Obama has taken about one-third as many vacation days as he predecessor.

Obamacare, climate change, immigration, the economy and entitlements - five topics down, one to go. Next time I'll be tackling a big one, and I have a lot to say on the subject: minimum wage.